Turns Out Victoria’s Second Wave Of COVID-19 Wasn’t Caused By Horny Security Guards
It looks like rumours of the "horny security guards" were started as a joke
“Patient zero” for Victoria’s second wave of coronavirus has been identified, and turns out it’s not a horny security guard.
In fact, it appears the salacious story that accused guards of spreading the virus across Melbourne after having sex with people in hotel quarantine is just that — a story.
There’s no debate that Victoria’s hotel quarantine program has been a huge disaster, with an inquiry currently investigating the quarantine breaches that took place. The decision to use private security guards — who were allegedly poorly trained in infection control, given inadequate PPE, and didn’t enforce social distancing — has been heavily criticised.
But according to leaked emails seen by The Age and The Sydney Morning Herald, it wasn’t a security guard who first caught the virus — it was a night duty manager at one of Melbourne’s busiest quarantine hotels.
On May 25 the night manager at Rydges on Swanston reported they had a fever, and late the next day hotel employees were told they’d tested positive.
It is presumed the employee caught it from a returned traveller, although it’s not known how they became infected. Sources told The Age and The Herald that a “green zone” that was supposed to be safe may not have been suitable to prevent cross-contamination.
This is a fantastically good story.
Patient zero in the hotel bungle, was hotel staff. And it wasn’t his fault.
Almost every case now in Vic comes from this it seems.
(have said repeatedly on air there was no evidence of guards sleeping with guests) https://t.co/XGG89XthZ8
— Rafael Epstein (@Raf_Epstein) August 13, 2020
After the positive result, seven security guards who were patrolling the hotel were stood down and told to isolate and get tested, as were a small number of hotel staff and health workers. Five of those guards returned positive tests, but it was too late — they spread the virus to their families in Melbourne’s northern and western suburbs, sparking the second wave.
According to The Age officials mistakenly reported that a security guard was the first positive test, but a senior official later corrected this and confirmed it was a hotel employee.
This all begs the questions — where did the rumour about security guards having sex with people in quarantine come from?
Back in July screenshots began circulating on Twitter which supposedly showed a Grindr conversation between a guard and someone in quarantine. Journalists were able to debunk it as a joke between friends.
Regardless, the story was picked up by other outlets and went viral.
FYI there's a tweet circulating that claims that they were messaged in quarantine by a security guard on Grindr.
I spoke to the person who posted it. He says it's fake: he claims it was a joke by a friend. pic.twitter.com/dZmysbORed
— friendlycammies (@cameronwilson) July 9, 2020
There was a screenshot floating around on Twitter of a Grindr convo purportedly between a guard and someone in quarantine. I asked that person about it and they said it was a joke with a friend.
I didn't report it and it hasn't ever really been substantiated. https://t.co/0dhPsao0PZ
— Josh Taylor (@joshgnosis) August 13, 2020
People are now criticising media outlets for spreading the story without proper fact-checking.
A lot of focus on “News Corp lies” about hotel quarantine / security guards, but on July 20 the AFR reported “rumours” that guards “traded sexual favours for letting people out of their rooms”
— Osman Faruqi (@oz_f) August 14, 2020
Meaty Henry clearly the Australian version of Deep Throat https://t.co/NQF0hVZajW
— Naaman Zhou (@naamanzhou) August 14, 2020
*I forlornly scratch Meaty Henry's name out of my contact book as an unreliable source* https://t.co/eajpANBrg7
— casey briggs (@CaseyBriggs) August 14, 2020
This is a disgrace, but it's not going to change. More pressing today: it turns out hundreds of stories and a series of entire news cycles have been predicated on a mistake. And the industry-wide response to that? Nothing at all. A Tower of Babel collapsing to eerie silence.
— Richard Cooke (@rgcooke) August 14, 2020
I can’t wait for the @ABCmediawatch episode about all this. https://t.co/NUtSF0t6RD
— Alison Smirnoff (@AlisonSmirnoff) August 13, 2020
A Rydges spokesperson said in a statement to Junkee that their employee who tested positive for COVID-19 did not spread the virus to colleagues or family members.
“Rydges on Swanston has been closed to guests since 27 March 2020 and has been operating under the direction of the Department of Jobs, Precincts and Regions (DJPR) and the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) as a Quarantine Hotel, at the request of the Victorian Government,” they confirmed.
“While it has been widely reported in the media [on Friday] that a staff member tested positive on 25 May, 2020, we wish to clarify that colleagues and family contacts of the staff member all tested negative, with the staff member isolating immediately upon getting tested.
“Rydges on Swanston is fully supportive of the Judicial Inquiry into the Hotel Quarantine Program and is currently assisting the Inquiry with its investigations. We look forward to clarification around the source of infection as the Inquiry findings are presented.”
Victoria’s inquiry into hotel quarantine is expected to report by November.