Melbourne Government Reverses Decision To Let Hundreds Attend Horse Race Despite Covid Risk
The initial announcement that 1250 could attend a massive Melbourne horse race caused immediate outcry.
Yesterday, the Melbourne government announced that up to 1250 people would be permitted to attend the Cox Plate Carnival, an annual horse race, despite the obvious coronavirus risk.
Melbourne is only a few days out of a strict lockdown. To suddenly allow hundreds to gather in a small space, when a matter of days ago it was not permitted to assemble in groups of ten or so, seemed inconsistent and cruel, and motivated solely by fear of the power of the lucrative horse-racing industry.
As a result, Twitter quickly became a hotbed of outrage, with many taking to their social media in order to express their displeasure, particularly targeting Martin Pakula, a Melbourne MP and the Victorian Racing Minister.
We just got our numbers down. Can’t have anyone at your house. 10 ppl can attend a funeral. You can’t move 25km+. But it’s okay to have 1000 people for horse racing.
📞 to say what you think:
Dan Andrews: (03) 9651 5000
Martin Pakula: (03) 8392 2221https://t.co/UGlV6T5Yie— fantastic ms. (@fox) October 20, 2020
I just cannot begin to comprehend why the Victorian Government approved this. They’ve got to be joking? Even if this got a public health approval the optics are enough to make everyone else think “fuck it, if the govt says it’s ok for 1000 race goers, I’ll have a GF party” https://t.co/SKnCUa1Ta7
— Matt Smithson (@mattsmithson) October 20, 2020
But only ten people can attend a funeral. And two families can’t watch the @afl grand final together. https://t.co/bpVQIjLnO8
— Dave Hughes (@DHughesy) October 20, 2020
Initially, Pakula — who has long ignored criticisms of the obvious cruelty and inhumanity of the racing industry — held fast against the outrage. He even tweeted “some context”, explaining that the Carnival required 750 staff to be there “anyway”, without realising that was a problem in and of itself: if 750 people have to be there, then the thing shouldn’t go on at all.
Tom. Some context. Of the 1000 people on course, 750 are there anyway – jockeys, trainers, barrier attendants, farriers, strappers & media. Of the rest, there’s no members, no fans, no bookies and the tote will be closed. Owners will come, watch the horse they own run, and leave https://t.co/MAOtx8zjIM
— Martin Pakula (@MartinPakulaMP) October 20, 2020
But within a couple of hours, and with public outcry mounting, Pakula announced that the decision had been reversed.
Tonight I’ve spoken to the Moonee Valley Racing Club and the decision’s been reversed. Owners won’t return to the race track until we reach the next stage of the easing of restrictions. I apologise for any upset that has been caused 2/2
— Martin Pakula (@MartinPakulaMP) October 20, 2020
Of course, Pakula is here only saying that additional lookers-on won’t be allowed to attend. The Cox Plate carnival will still allow hundreds of staff to be present. Clearly, there’s still an inconsistency of rules between those for most Melbournians, and those for the horse race industry.