Over 40,000 People Sign Petition To Shut Down Jacinda Ardern Film About The Christchurch Attack
The proposed film, titled 'They Are Us' has led to #TheyAreUsShutDown trending for days.
On Thursday it was announced that a film about the New Zealand government’s response to the Christchurch Massacre was in the works, starring Australian actor, Rose Byrne as Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern.
The film titled They Are Us would follow Jacinda Ardern’s leadership during the 2019 attack on a Christchurch mosque that claimed the lives of 52 Muslims.
The proposed film has been met with nothing short of condemnation. A change.org petition currently sitting at over 47,000 signatures is demanding the film be shut down. The hashtag, #TheyAreUsShutdown was also trending for several days.
You can tell how far removed this film is from the community affected and from New Zealand itself by (1) THE NAME and (2) anyone thinking Jacinda Ardern was the main character. https://t.co/I79lp5TZwp
— Charlotte Graham-McLay شارلوت (@CGrahamMcLay) June 10, 2021
“They Are Us is not so much about the attack but the response to the attack.” Yes, the murder of 51 Muslims people is only the backdrop to the story of a how a white woman became a great leader. BIPOC are really just props in this white peoples world. #TheyAreUsShutDown
— Shaneel Lal (They/Them) (@shaneellall) June 10, 2021
Aotearoa's Muslim community were the ones unseen & unheard. It was their pleas to police for help that were dismissed prior to Chch. Their voices are ONLY ones to elevate & amplify, not a political leader who was plastered all over world media at the time, FFS #TheyAreUsShutDown https://t.co/Wp0qvur46d
— tanyafretz (@tanyafretz) June 11, 2021
Ardern herself addressed the film’s content and backlash saying, “While it’s for the community to speak for themselves, it’s my view March 15 [2019] remains very raw for New Zealand,” she said in a statement. “There are plenty of stories from March 15 that could be told, but I don’t consider mine to be one of them.”
The title, They Are Us, refers to the mantra taken from Ardern’s powerful speech describing the New Zealand Muslims who were victims of the attack. Even at the time, many New Zealand Muslims feared the use of ‘they’ was still othering them, and would be used to center others in the tragedy.
This really is a no-brainer. Listen to the victims of march 15 and sign the petition now: https://t.co/mQNHaUleHW#TheyAreUsShutDown pic.twitter.com/non4Be7v46
— Guled Mire (@GuledMire) June 11, 2021
Its official NZ hates #TheyAreUs more than we love Lorde (and we really love Lorde). #TheyAreUsShutdown #ShutItDown #KakaIdeas pic.twitter.com/v2F7b1IAzV
— Tina Ngata (@tinangata) June 11, 2021
To everyone saying "Too Soon"…
There will NEVER be a good time to decenter the actual victims and their families.
Not later, not ever.#TheyAreUsShutDown
— Tina Ngata (@tinangata) June 11, 2021
“There are families still fighting the government and ACC for compensation. Others who feel silenced and ignored by police, intelligence and a Royal Commission that failed to hold anyone to account,” writes Mohamed Hassan of survivors of the attack in RNZ. “There were times when ‘They Are Us’ felt hollow. A promise made but not kept. A pat on the back for a job not yet done.”
Hassan summarised the New Zealand Muslim, and general Muslim community’s anger at the film succinctly. They write, “In its essence, it is a story about an act of white supremacy that is centred around white voices, white feelings and white heroism.”
Here's my hot take on #TheyAreUsShutDown – I told you so (that white people would mobilise & weaponise #TheyAreUs to benefit their own white saviour/shero narratives, and in doing so, marginalise the f** outta us Kiwi Muslims). It was never about 'us'.
— Hala (@_halansr) June 11, 2021
Thousands signed a petition to stop a Hollywood film about the New Zealand mosque attacks. It will reportedly focus on PM Jacinda Ardern's response — not the 51 Muslims killed, their families or survivors.
Muslims make up just 1.1% of characters in top U.S. films, says a study. pic.twitter.com/2qRAHMUaDA
— AJ+ (@ajplus) June 11, 2021
You do not get to tell this story. You do not get to white wash, glorify the pain and suffering of our community. #TheyAreUsShutDown https://t.co/JEQMA91siY
— Ahmed Osman (@Ahmed_Osman26) June 11, 2021
Along with Jacinda Ardern and her government’s distancing from the film and calls for the film to be shut down, Maori activist Kera O’Regan has also called for direct action. “Say no to them using your locations. Say no to hiring gear. Say no to being talent. Say no to being crew. Say no to interviewing them or promoting on your media platforms,” they tweeted.
The islamophobic Christchurch attack of 2019 saw the lives of over 50 Muslims lost. While Jacinda Ardern’s actions as a leader were admirable, it is an act devoid of empathy to make the hate crime and loss of life that occurred that day a backdrop to another woman’s story.